Friday, April 8, 2011
Young Students and On Line Learning
I read with interest the article and responses concerning young students and on line learning. During my graduate course work, I have had the opportunity to participate in both live and on line classes and have slowly started to formulate my own opinions concerning on line learning. In addition, our short experience with the on line education forum has provided additional food for thought concerning on line learning. While I think on line learning my have a place for some students, for the majority of young learners, I believe the traditional classroom setting or a hybrid classroom is the most ideal learning environment. First, I believe students need to have a classroom environment that allows for summative assessments which include the use of verbal and nonverbal cues or clues. As a classroom teacher, an educator can constantly assess if a student is understanding and comprehending a concept or topic almost immediately based on a student's physical reaction. This is almost impossible with an on line class. Sure emoticons are available but just like in a regular classroom, how many student will tell you they don't get it or say they have a question if something is not making sense to them? Also, an educator can offer immediate feedback when a student may not be on the right track. Thus, allowing the student to redirect their thought processes and know more success in the classroom. For example, when I took my online class, we did not receive points for our assignments for a week or so. When the grade was posted, there were no comments or feedback to what was wrong and how it could be fixed. There were time when several additional assignments had been completed the same way before the feedback had been obtained and applied to additional assignments. Second, I believe educators need to have face time with students in order to know if the lesson concept is being comprehended. I believe there needs to be a healthy classroom dialog concerning the subject matter and higher order questions asked of students to ignite the thinking process and further develop critical thinking. For example, when we completed our on line forum mini presentations, I had developed what I wanted to convey to the audience concerning my active learning strategy and presented it without tripping over my tongue too many times. However, I have no idea how the presentation was received by the listeners, what areas were confusing and/or what areas needed just a little more explanation. There was no connection with the learning audience and no way for me to assess the effectiveness of my lesson/presentation. I believe this is a huge disadvantage. Third, I believe students can benefit from the (sometimes forced) interaction with faculty, staff and other students in an educational setting. As a society, we have become far too comfortable with hiding behind a screen and have lost the ability to communicate and interact socially with other individuals. While not all occupations will require these type of soft skills, many still do and our young learners will not have the opportunity to practice and hone this skills if they exclusively learn on line. Education to me is more than just learning what is required by our state standards. Young students in a traditional classroom are learning how to adapt to an environment, work with a team, struggle through adversity, celebrate success, navigate the cafe, interact with other students, talk to adults, stay focused with distractions and survive outside the comfort zone.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Brenda, I agree with your thoughts on online learning for high school students. I think the interaction between students and faculty are necessary for students to learn the "soft skills" necessary for societal norms. I equally agree with your thoughts on being able to see the student's faces in order to determine if learning is taking place or not. Although I have only been student teaching for a couple months, I am better able to determine those students who understand and those who need more information based on their facial expressions.
ReplyDeleteI agree with what you said about giving feedback to students. Students need constant feedback throughout the learning process. It is especially important when they are being assessed. We must give the students opportunity to improve and grow!
ReplyDelete